Abstract
It isn't a reliability rating across all cars. A 3 on one model and a 3 on another don't make the two equally good. Each one sits in the middle of its own model's range.
Keywords: car model year score, years to avoid, NHTSA complaints, car recalls, best years
1. What a score means
A score answers one question: is this year of the car better or worse than the model's other years? Ratings built from owner surveys usually measure a car against other cars, either all of them or its own class [6, 7]. Ours never leaves the model, so it can't tell you whether one model beats another.
| Score | Label | Index (Section 4) |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Among the best | Up to 0.6 |
| 4 | Better than most | Over 0.6, up to 0.9 |
| 3 | Middle of the range | Over 0.9, up to 1.3 |
| 2 | Worse than most | Over 1.3, up to 2.0 |
| 1 | Among the worst | Over 2.0 |
2. Data sources
Every count comes from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), the federal regulator that collects owner complaints and runs recalls.
| Count | Source |
|---|---|
| Complaints | Owner complaints filed against the model year, from NHTSA's complaint database [1] |
| Serious complaints | The same complaints, counting only those that report a crash, a fire, an injury or a death [1] |
| Recalls | Recall campaigns NHTSA lists for the model year, issued in the year's five-year window [2] |
| Open probes | NHTSA defect investigations still open on the read date [3] |
Our model pages cover every model year in NHTSA's file from 2000 on, because used-car buyers still shop those years. Our symptom guides, code pages and complaint data file use one fixed window, model years 2010–2025, so their figures can be checked against each other.
3. Why the first five years on the road
An older year has had more time to collect complaints than a newer one. So complaints, serious complaints and recalls are counted over the same window: the year's own model year and the four calendar years after it. For a 2003 car, that means complaints received from 2003 to 2007 and recalls issued by the end of 2007, including any issued before the 2003 went on sale. Open probes are counted on the read date.
The window gives each year equal time, but it can't make the years equal in every other way. Complaint habits can change over time, which our five-year window only partly evens out. A year younger than five has no full window yet, so it gets no score.
4. The formula
Each of the four counts is divided by the model's median for that count: the middle value of the count across all the model's scored years, or the average of the two middle values when the number of years is even. Then the four ratios are weighted and added into one index:
- C
- Complaints in the year's five-year window
- S
- Serious complaints, those reporting a crash, a fire, an injury or a death
- R
- Recall campaigns issued in the window
- P
- Open NHTSA probes on the read date, counted as 1 + P so that a year with none still divides cleanly
- med
- The model's median for the same count
Complaints and serious complaints carry most of the weight, because they're what owners lived with. An index of 1 means the four weighted ratios add up to the same as a year at every median, though one count can sit above it and another below. The index sets the score:
5. Special rules
- Do Not Drive. A year scores 1, whatever its index, when a recall issued in that year's first five years tells owners not to drive it. A do-not-drive recall issued later, such as a later Takata air bag recall on NHTSA's Do Not Drive list [4], shows on the car page and does not change the score. A year still on NHTSA's Takata Do Not Drive list or with an open do-not-drive recall is never listed as a best year. A recall that only holds unsold cars at the dealer doesn't count. The list names only some cars of those years, so a year's score is not your car's recall status. Check your own car by its VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls.
- Too few complaints. A year with fewer than 10 complaints and no recall in its five-year window shows no score, because a handful of reports can't be compared.
- Too new to judge. A year under five years old shows no score, because its window isn't complete.
- Best years start at 2011. Model year 2011 is the first of NHTSA's current five-star crash tests, so a best year that NHTSA rated was rated on today's scale [5].
- Best years score 5. A car page's Best list shows up to five years from 2011 on: the years that score 5, then the years that score 4 under Next best: better than most. A year that scores 3 or less, a year with no score, and a year still on NHTSA's Takata Do Not Drive list or with an open do-not-drive recall are never on it. When fewer years qualify, the list is shorter.
- Older models. When a model's last year is before 2011, its Best list shows its best-scoring older years, each marked as an older year. A year that scores 1 or 2, or is on NHTSA's Takata Do Not Drive list or under an open do-not-drive recall, is never on it.
- Avoid and Check. The Avoid list shows up to five years that score 1, do-not-drive years first. When more than five years score 1, the others are named under the list. Under it, Check before you buy lists the years that score 2. No other year is added to either list.
- Ties. Two years with the same index to two decimals are ranked newer year first.
6. A worked example
The 2003 Honda Accord, measured against the Accord's 22 scored model years, 2000 to 2021.
| Count | 2003 | Model median | Ratio | Weight | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Complaints, 2003–2007 | 543 | 265.5 | 2.045 | 40% | 0.818 |
| Serious complaints, same years | 81 | 33.5 | 2.418 | 40% | 0.967 |
| Recalls issued, 2003–2007 | 8 | 3 | 2.667 | 15% | 0.400 |
| Open probes (1 + count) | 3 | 2 | 1.500 | 5% | 0.075 |
| Index | 2.260 |
The 2003 drew about twice its model's median in complaints and about 2.4 times in serious complaints, and an index of 2.260 is above 2.0. So the 2003 Accord scores 1 of 5, among the worst Accord years.
7. Limitations
Complaints aren't verified. NHTSA publishes what owners write, and a count shows who wrote in, not how often a car broke. Some owners never file at all.
We don't divide by sales, because carmakers publish sales by calendar year, not by model year. Dividing by the model's own median removes how popular the model is, but not its swings from one year to the next, such as a launch year or a redesign.
A score describes a model year, not the car in front of you. Its own history and an inspection will tell you more.
8. Updates and versions
We read the federal files again every 3 months, and scores can change when the data is re-read. The current scores use the complaint file of August 25, 2026, the recalls read October 3, 2026 and the investigation file of September 2, 2026. The next check is due in January 2027, and each January the newest model year that has completed its five-year window gets its first score.
9. Open data
The owner complaint counts behind every car page are on our data page as a CSV for model years 2010–2025, one row per model year and component. The scores file sits beside it, one row per model year with the four counts, the score and its label, so you can recompute any score. Both are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with credit to Oil & Miles.
10. Review
Iqbal Taher runs a family repair and parts business that has been open since 1998, and he has worked in it as a mechanic and parts trader since 2011. He reviews the method and the federal records each car page cites, the way a mechanic reads a car's history before quoting a repair.
11. Corrections log
Found a score that looks wrong? Email contact@oilandmiles.com with the car and the year, and we'll check it against the federal records.
Each fix is listed here with its date. None so far.
12. Method history
- Version 1.1, November 14, 2026. Do-not-drive window, no do-not-drive year in Best, too few complaints, list rules written out.
- Version 1.0, October 31, 2026. Complaints 40%, serious complaints 40%, recalls 15% and open probes 5%, each against the model's median over the year's first five years, in five score bands.
References
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, consumer complaint database, file of August 25, 2026.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, recall campaigns by vehicle, read October 3, 2026.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Office of Defects Investigation, open investigations, file of September 2, 2026.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, "Critical Do Not Drive Warning for Certain Vehicles with Takata Air Bags," read October 30, 2026.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, New Car Assessment Program, 5-Star Safety Ratings, read October 30, 2026.
- Consumer Reports, "Car Reliability FAQ" and Data Intelligence "Rating Methods," read October 30, 2026.
- J.D. Power, "Ratings Methodology," read October 30, 2026.
How to cite this note
Taher, I. (2026). How we score car model years: The Oil & Miles complaint method (Version 1.1). Oil & Miles. https://oilandmiles.com/methodology/car-year-scores
@misc{taher_2026_year_scores,
author = {Taher, Iqbal},
title = {How we score car model years: The Oil & Miles complaint method},
year = {2026},
publisher = {Oil \& Miles},
version = {1.1},
url = {https://oilandmiles.com/methodology/car-year-scores}
}