Key takeaways
- The specification code in your owner's manual decides which oil your engine needs, not the word synthetic.
- Buy an oil that carries that code in the grade the manual names, whatever its label says.
- If the manual names only a grade, conventional oil with the current API mark is fine on its schedule.
- Don't stretch the oil change interval to pay for synthetic, because that uses up the extra protection.
- You can switch between synthetic and conventional at any oil change, with no flush needed.
The usual answer on synthetic vs conventional oil is that synthetic is built molecule by molecule in a laboratory and conventional comes out of the ground. It's a tidy story and it's mostly wrong.
Much of the oil sold as full synthetic in the United States is refined crude, and an advertising industry panel accepted calling it synthetic in 1999. What a bottle actually promises is a specification code on the back label, and the owner's manual names the one your engine needs.
Synthetic vs conventional oil: what is the measurable difference?
Marketing claims about protection are hard to check, but NOACK volatility isn't: it asks how much oil evaporates in an hour at 250°C, which is roughly what the oil above the pistons experiences. The test is ASTM D5800 and the result is a percentage of weight lost.
| Oil | NOACK loss | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional passenger car oil | About 12–13%, AAA 2017 | More of it leaves as vapor, and what remains is thicker than what you poured in |
| Synthetic passenger car oil | About 8–10%, AAA 2017 | Less loss, so less of it boils off |
| API SQ / ILSAC GF-7A limit | 15% maximum | The limit current SQ and GF-7A oils must clear, as SP and GF-6A did before them |
| GM dexos limit | 12.5% maximum, by published summaries | Tighter than API, and this is where it gets interesting |
NOACK is one number you can check, set against the limits API, ILSAC and GM set.
A dexos1 limit that tight can rule out much conventional oil on its own, and GM's manual asks for full synthetic by name as well, which is the mechanism behind every "your car requires synthetic" conversation at a service counter. The specification did the excluding, not the marketing.
Oil that boils off leaves the oil pan, which is one of the routes by which an engine appears to burn oil, and what stays behind is heavier than the grade on the bottle. The grade on the bottle describes the oil when it's fresh, and 0W-20 vs 5W-30 shows what that grade is worth.
What do the two words actually mean?
They name where an oil's base oil sits in API's five groups. Base oil is the oil before additives go in. Its group sets a starting point, and the additives do the rest.
Groups I and II are refined crude, and Group II is what "conventional" means on an American shelf today. Group III is usually the same crude taken much further, hydrocracked (reworked with hydrogen under high pressure) to reach a viscosity index of 120 or more.
Group IV is polyalphaolefin, genuinely assembled from small molecules. Group V is everything else, mostly esters, usually blended in rather than sold alone.
| Group | How it is made | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| Group I | Solvent refined | Under 90% saturates or over 0.03% sulfur. The old conventional oil |
| Group II | Hydroprocessed | At least 90% saturates, low sulfur. Most conventional oil sold today |
| Group III | Severely hydrocracked | Same purity, viscosity index 120 or above. Sold as synthetic in the US |
| Group IV | Polyalphaolefin | Built molecule by molecule. The thing people picture when they say synthetic |
| Group V | Everything else | Esters and the rest, usually blended in rather than used alone |
Groups II and III are both refined crude, which is where the word synthetic stops meaning what buyers think.
How do you pick the oil for your own car?
It comes down to one code in the manual, and the first step is finding out whether yours names one:
- Open the manual and find the specification. A code such as dexos1, WSS-M2C970-A1 or VW 504.00, not just a grade. How to read an oil bottle shows where it appears on the back label.
- Buy an oil that carries that code, in the grade the manual names. If only synthetics carry it, that's your answer and it didn't require an opinion.
- If the manual names only a grade, buy that grade with the current API mark. Conventional is fine where it's sold in that grade: change it on the conventional schedule and you've met what the maker asks for.
- Don't buy synthetic and then stretch it past the manual's interval to pay for it. The longer interval uses up the extra protection you paid for.
Makers word the requirement differently, as the manuals section below shows. So read your own manual's words before you buy.
What does synthetic actually buy you?
Three things, and they're worth different amounts depending on how you drive. AAA's 2017 tests put synthetic an average of 47 percent better across a variety of industry-standard tests, which isn't a measure of engine life.
So where a maker asks for synthetic, it's asking for a set of test results too, and synthetic is the route to passing them, with three real advantages over conventional oil:
- Cold starts. Synthetic base stock stays fluid at lower temperatures, so oil reaches the top of the engine faster on a winter morning. Cold starts are hard on an engine.
- Heat tolerance. Lower volatility and better oxidation resistance mean it degrades more slowly under sustained load: towing, mountains, hot climates, small turbocharged engines.
- Interval. The extended drain interval on a modern car assumes an oil that survives it. That assumption is part of what the price buys.
If your driving is mixed in a mild climate in a naturally aspirated engine, the margin is real but you may never see it. Short trips are harder on oil of either kind, so follow the manual's severe schedule if it has one, and a turbocharged three-cylinder in traffic uses every bit of it.
What doesn't it buy you?
Three things people expect from synthetic that it doesn't do:
- A bottle isn't a sludge cure. Mobil and Valvoline say detergents can clear deposits over time, Valvoline over four or more changes on its own test. Heavy sludge is a job for a shop, not a bottle.
- Switching doesn't normally cause leaks in older engines. This one has a real origin: some seals shrink in contact with PAO, a common synthetic base stock, and modern synthetics are formulated with seal compatibility in mind. What actually happens is that an old, hard, already-leaking seal keeps leaking, and the oil that was in the engine when you noticed gets the blame.
- There's no commitment. You can switch to synthetic and back again, in either direction, at any oil change. No flush is needed and nothing is locked in.
On an older engine, sources split. AAA says many mechanics favor conventional past 75,000 miles, and Consumer Reports says synthetic's lower sludge suits older cars.
Either is fine if it meets the manual. Mobil says to change it sooner for the first few oil changes after a switch on a high-mileage or neglected engine.
Is it worth the money?
Usually yes on a modern engine. The main drawback is the price, a little more at each oil change. Set against that, a modern turbocharged engine runs its oil hotter than a 1990s four-cylinder did, and service intervals have stretched.
The oil is also doing more jobs than lubrication alone. On some engines it operates variable valve timing, and on a few it is the environment a timing belt lives in.
The front of the bottle won't tell you which oil suits your engine. The mark that decides it is explained in how to read an oil bottle.
What is the difference between full synthetic and a blend?
A synthetic blend is exactly what the name says: synthetic and conventional base oils mixed deliberately, priced between the two. It's a mix, and the bottle rarely gives the ratio.
The question people actually mean when they ask about the difference between synthetic and full synthetic is usually this one: is the blend enough? If it carries the specification your manual names, it is.
And since the blend is a mixture by design, it settles a related worry: mixing synthetic and conventional oil in your own engine isn't dangerous either. The industry bottles the mixture.
Why is Group III allowed to say synthetic?
Because an advertising panel decided in 1999 that it could, and the decision still stands. In March 1999 Mobil complained to the Better Business Bureau's National Advertising Division that Castrol Syntec, made from hydrocracked petroleum rather than constructed molecules, shouldn't be sold as synthetic.
The NAD found for Castrol. Leaning on industry references, it held that Castrol had a reasonable basis for the claim, because hydrocracking makes the base oil through an intended chemical reaction.
So synthetic became a marketing term rather than a technical one. A bottle marked full synthetic may hold Group III, Group IV, or a mixture, and no rule requires the bottle to tell you which.
Worth knowing
A good Group III oil outperforms a mediocre Group IV one, because the additive package counts as well as the base stock. Buying by group would be no smarter than buying by label, and buying by specification is the thing that works.
From the carmakers
What do owner's manuals ask for?
Each maker words the oil requirement its own way: one asks for full synthetic with an approval, one moves lesser oil to a shorter schedule, and one allows a synthetic as a fallback. The manual for your engine settles the choice, not the label on the bottle.
Owner's manual 2020 Equinox
Use full synthetic engine oils that meet the dexos1 specification.
Owner's manual 2023 Sonata
If a lower grade engine oil (mineral oil including Semi-synthetic) is used, then the engine oil and engine oil filter must be replaced as indicated for severe maintenance condition.
Owner's manual 2020 Altima
If the above motor oil (or engine oil) is not available, a synthetic 0W-20 GF-5 SN motor oil (or engine oil) may be used.
Conclusion
What to do next about synthetic or conventional oil
Where a manual names dexos1, WSS-M2C970-A1 or VW 504.00, only oils carrying that code qualify, and on most of those codes that means synthetic by default rather than by argument. Where the manual names a grade and nothing else, conventional oil is a sound arrangement, changed on the conventional schedule.
Oil & Miles checks each figure here against API's own tables and the makers' manuals, across oil and fluids.
Common questions
Asked most often
Does full synthetic mean anything on a label?
Nothing consistent, because neither term is regulated: in practice "full synthetic" is used to distinguish a product from a synthetic blend.
Is synthetic oil worth it?
If your manual requires a specification that conventional oil can't meet, the question doesn't arise. If it doesn't, it depends on your climate, your engine and your intervals, and the answer can legitimately be no.
Does synthetic oil last twice as long?
It degrades more slowly, but the interval is set by the manufacturer for a whole system, not by the oil alone. Follow the manual's figure rather than the bottle's implication.
What people ask next
Sources
- Mobil and Valvoline on their own oils, for what each says about deposits, and Mobil on the first changes after a switch. These are the makers' claims. Mobil and Valvoline, read November 2, 2026
- AAA on synthetic and conventional oil, for what many mechanics favor past 75,000 miles. AAA, read November 2, 2026
- Consumer Reports on synthetic oil, for synthetic being less likely to form sludge. Consumer Reports, read November 2, 2026
- AAA oil research report and newsroom release, June 2017, for the NOACK losses of five conventional and five synthetic oils, the 47 percent and the yearly cost. AAA, read November 2, 2026
- Manufacturer manuals, read at source for how makers word an oil requirement: the 2023 Hyundai Sonata, the 2020 Nissan Altima and the 2020 Chevrolet Equinox, which asks for full synthetic oils that meet dexos1. Manufacturer owner manuals, read August 26, 2026
- API 1509 Annex E: base oil interchangeability guidelines, for the definitions of Groups I to V used here, including the saturates, sulfur and viscosity-index boundaries that separate Group II from Group III. American Petroleum Institute
- “Synthetic” as the word relates to motor oil, for its account of the 1999 National Advertising Division decision on Mobil's March 1999 complaint against Castrol Syntec, which is why Group III can be sold as synthetic in the US. Porsche Club of America
- API 1509, 24th edition, July 2026, amended September 23, 2026, Table G-8 (API SQ) and Table H-8 (ILSAC GF-7A), for the 15.0% maximum NOACK evaporation loss. American Petroleum Institute, read October 3, 2026
- The NOACK volatility test, ASTM D5800, for the method. BG Products laboratory
- GM dexos specification, for GM's NOACK limit, 12.5% for the current dexos1 edition. We couldn't read GM's own document. Published dexos specification summaries
AI illustration by Oil & Miles
General information about oil specifications, compiled August 2026 for the US market. Specification limits are revised periodically. Your owner's manual and the manufacturer's current approved-oils list are the authority for your engine. See the disclaimer.



