A high-mileage car interior: worn, torn seat bolster and a shiny worn steering wheel.

High-Mileage Cars to Avoid: 22 Ranked Worst to Best

Short answer: The high mileage cars to avoid are the Chevrolet Equinox, Nissan Sentra, Kia Optima, Nissan Rogue and Ford Focus. Of 22 models in 48,481 federal safety complaints, they have the highest share describing a repair of $1,000 or more. Buy one only after a cold start and an independent inspection aimed at its known fault, or start with the seven lowest.

Iqbal Taher Written by Iqbal Taher Certified engine mechanic and parts trader since 2011
Fact checked

Key takeaways

  • Each model's share counts complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, not how often the car breaks.
  • Each of the 22 cars names its main fault and the model year with the highest share.
  • Ask for the car cold, because several faults show only in the first minutes after a start.
  • Book an independent inspection aimed at the model's named fault, and walk away if the seller refuses it.
  • Run the VIN, as the Optima and Sonata engine warranties, Elantra 2.0L program and 2014 Civic recall are open.

This list of high mileage cars to avoid ranks 22 mainstream models from 2012, 2014 and 2016, the cars you'll find on sale with an estimated 110,000–150,000 miles. For each model it gives the share of owners' complaints that describe a repair of $1,000 or more, and names the fault to check.

Which high mileage cars to avoid come out worst?

The Chevrolet Equinox comes out worst, on oil consumption, ahead of the Nissan Sentra on its CVT, a gearless automatic. The Kia Optima on engine failure, the Nissan Rogue on its CVT and the Ford Focus on its dual-clutch, an automatic that shifts with two clutches, complete the worst five.

Each car's main fault is the one its complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more name most, though other parts can still break. Each count shows how many of a model's complaints describe a repair of $1,000 or more. The bold year is the model year with the largest share of them.

A CVT alone says little about the bill, since the Sentra and the Rogue are second and fourth while the Civic and the Corolla sit in the bottom four. CVT problems by maker explains why Nissan's CVTs stand apart.

All 22 cars at a glance: rank and main fault
Worst first. From NHTSA complaints on 2012, 2014 and 2016 models, complaint file dated August 25, 2026.
#Car Main fault
1Chevrolet Equinox Oil consumption
2Nissan Sentra CVT automatic
3Kia Optima Engine failure
4Nissan Rogue CVT automatic
5Ford Focus Dual-clutch
6Toyota Camry Transmission
7Hyundai Sonata Engine failure
8Nissan Altima CVT automatic
9Subaru Outback CVT automatic
10Ford Escape Transmission
11Subaru Forester Oil consumption
12Hyundai Elantra Engine failure
13Chevrolet Cruze Head gasket
14Honda CR-VTiming chain
15Volkswagen Jetta Timing chain
16Ford Fusion Engine failure
17Honda Accord Transmission
18Toyota RAV4Transmission
19Honda Civic CVT automatic
20Chevrolet Malibu Engine failure
21Jeep Grand Cherokee Transmission
22Toyota Corolla CVT automatic

1. Chevrolet Equinox

Main fault
Oil consumption
$1,000+ repairs
419 of 1,623
Free repair program
Ended

About one in four Equinox complaints describes a repair of $1,000 or more, mostly oil use, worst on the 2012 at 30%. GM's 16118-01 piston cover has ended.

Chevrolet Equinox problems by year →

Chevrolet Equinox

2. Nissan Sentra

Main fault
CVT automatic
$1,000+ repairs
197 of 828
Free repair program
Mostly ended

The CVT leads the Sentra's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2014 at 26%. Nissan's CVT extension has run out on most cars. If it cuts power at highway speed, pull over safely.

Which CVTs fail and why →

Nissan Sentra

3. Kia Optima

Main fault
Engine failure
$1,000+ repairs
377 of 2,252
Free repair program
Lifetime

Engine failure leads the Optima's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2016 at 25%. Kia's lifetime short block cover needs the knock sensor update, so run the VIN.

Kia models by year →

Kia Optima

4. Nissan Rogue

Main fault
CVT automatic
$1,000+ repairs
215 of 1,291
Free repair program
Mostly ended

The CVT leads the Rogue's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2012 at 27%, a year Nissan's CVT extension never covered.

Nissan Rogue problems by year →

Nissan Rogue

5. Ford Focus

Main fault
Dual-clutch
$1,000+ repairs
1,172 of 7,537
Free repair program
Mostly ended

The Focus dual-clutch transmission draws the most complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more here, worst on the 2014 at 20%. Watch for a shudder or a loss of drive. Ford's 14M01, 19N08 and 14M02 covers have mostly ended.

Ford Focus problems by year →

Ford Focus

6. Toyota Camry

Main fault
Transmission
$1,000+ repairs
180 of 1,224
Free repair program
Ended

Transmission faults lead the Camry's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2014 at 18%, while the 2016 drops to 3%. Toyota's ZE5 torque converter cover has ended, so have a mechanic check the transmission.

Toyota Camry problems by year →

Toyota Camry

7. Hyundai Sonata

Main fault
Engine failure
$1,000+ repairs
432 of 3,019
Free repair program
Lifetime

Engine failure leads the Sonata's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2016 at 28%. Hyundai's lifetime Theta II engine cover needs the knock sensor update, so run the VIN.

Hyundai Sonata problems by year →

Hyundai Sonata

8. Nissan Altima

Main fault
CVT automatic
$1,000+ repairs
287 of 2,090
Free repair program
Mostly ended

The CVT leads the Altima's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2012 at 20%, a year Nissan's CVT extension left out.

Nissan Altima problems by year →

Nissan Altima

9. Subaru Outback

Main fault
CVT automatic
$1,000+ repairs
130 of 1,143
Free repair program
Mostly ended

The CVT leads the Outback's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2012 at 28%, against 3% for the 2016. Subaru's CVT extensions 16-107-17R and 16-115-18 have mostly ended, so ask a dealer to check the VIN.

Subaru Outback problems by year →

Subaru Outback

10. Ford Escape

Main fault
Transmission
$1,000+ repairs
396 of 3,764
Free repair program
None found

Transmission faults lead the Escape's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2016 at 13%, close to the 2014's 12%.

Ford Escape problems by year →

Ford Escape

11. Subaru Forester

Main fault
Oil consumption
$1,000+ repairs
73 of 918
Free repair program
Ended

Oil use leads the Forester's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2012 at 17%, against 2% for the 2016. Subaru's 02-157-14R oil use cover has ended.

Do high-mileage cars burn oil? →

Subaru Forester

12. Hyundai Elantra

Main fault
Engine failure
$1,000+ repairs
103 of 1,323
Free repair program
Open

Engine failure leads the Elantra's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2014 at 13%. Hyundai's 22-EM-006H-2 cover for the 2.0L engine is still open, so run the VIN.

Hyundai Elantra problems by year →

Hyundai Elantra

13. Chevrolet Cruze

Main fault
Head gasket
$1,000+ repairs
141 of 1,813
Free repair program
None found

A head gasket leads the Cruze's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2014 at 9%. It starts with a stumble or a coolant tank running low.

Chevrolet Cruze problems by year →

Chevrolet Cruze

14. Honda CR-V

Main fault
Timing chain
$1,000+ repairs
100 of 1,375
Free repair program
None found

Timing chain faults lead the CR-V's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2014 at 9%. Honda traces its cold-start rattle to the VTC actuator, not the chain.

Honda CR-V problems by year →

Honda CR-V

15. Volkswagen Jetta

Main fault
Timing chain
$1,000+ repairs
58 of 1,045
Free repair program
Ended

Timing chain faults lead the Jetta's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, worst on the 2014 at 9%. VW's VWP-18-07 chain cover has ended, so ask for a cold start and an inspection aimed at the chain.

Bad timing chain symptoms →

Volkswagen Jetta

Which cars hold up best at high mileage?

The Toyota Corolla comes out best on this measure, then the Jeep Grand Cherokee, Chevrolet Malibu, Honda Civic, Toyota RAV4, Honda Accord and Ford Fusion. Taken together across the three years, none of these seven has more than 4% of its complaints on a repair of $1,000 or more.

If you're buying at a distance, start at the bottom of the list, well away from the used cars to avoid at the top. Our free car complaints lookup shows what owners of the exact car have filed, though an inspection still decides it.

16. Ford Fusion

Main fault
Engine failure
$1,000+ repairs
214 of 5,445
Free repair program
None found

Only 4% of the Fusion's complaints describe a repair of $1,000 or more, mostly engine failure. The 2016 runs higher at 9%, so check that year hard.

Ford Fusion problems by year →

Ford Fusion

17. Honda Accord

Main fault
Transmission
$1,000+ repairs
74 of 1,946
Free repair program
None found

Transmission faults lead the Accord's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, and even its worst year, the 2014, stays at 5%.

Honda Accord problems by year →

Honda Accord

18. Toyota RAV4

Main fault
Transmission
$1,000+ repairs
24 of 694
Free repair program
Ended

Transmission faults lead the RAV4's few complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more. The 2014 runs higher at 7%, so check it harder. Toyota's ZH1 torque converter cover has ended.

Toyota RAV4 problems by year →

Toyota RAV4

19. Honda Civic

Main fault
CVT automatic
$1,000+ repairs
58 of 1,817
Free repair program
Open by VIN

The 2014 Civic is the exception at this end, at 14%, mostly its CVT. Recall 15V-574 gives certain 2014s a free CVT software update, so check the VIN.

Honda Civic problems by year →

Honda Civic

20. Chevrolet Malibu

Main fault
Engine failure
$1,000+ repairs
55 of 2,090
Free repair program
Ended

Engine failure leads the Malibu's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, and no year passes 4%, with the 2014 highest. GM's N182195660 piston program for certain 1.5L cars ended in 2022.

Chevrolet Malibu problems by year →

Chevrolet Malibu

21. Jeep Grand Cherokee

Main fault
Transmission
$1,000+ repairs
105 of 4,319
Free repair program
None found

Transmission faults lead the Grand Cherokee's complaints about a repair of $1,000 or more, with the 2016 highest at 3%. A third of its complaints are about electrics.

Jeep Grand Cherokee problems by year →

Jeep Grand Cherokee

22. Toyota Corolla

Main fault
CVT automatic
$1,000+ repairs
19 of 925
Free repair program
None found

The Corolla has the lowest share of the 22, with the 2016 highest at 4%. Over half its complaints concern air bags, so check the VIN for an open recall.

Toyota Corolla problems by year →

Toyota Corolla

What usually goes wrong on a high-mileage car?

A worn transmission, oil burning and a head gasket are the big faults past 100,000 miles, with timing belts, leaks and tired parts close behind. Each one below has its own page with the signs and the cost, and what keeping up with all of it costs is on our 100k mile maintenance cost page.

Transmission: a worn CVT or a slipping automatic

A CVT has no gears to shift badly, so wear shows up as noise, shudder or slipping instead. If it suddenly cuts power at highway speed, pull over safely, and our page on which CVTs fail and why covers the rest.

On a geared automatic, the engine note rises but the car doesn't speed up to match, and every slip turns into heat, so it gets worse fast. Low fluid is the first, cheapest thing to check, as our page on transmission slipping explains.

Engine: oil, gaskets, ticks and the timing belt

Most high-mileage engines use a little oil, but one that needs topping off between every change needs a proper measurement. A head gasket starts small, with a stumble at a light or a coolant tank running low a week after you filled it.

Some ticks after a cold start are normal, like the fuel injectors, while others mean a part is short of oil. A timing belt past its interval is a job to price before you buy, so check what the belt job costs.

Old valve cover and oil pan gaskets seep, and the bill is mostly labor, which is why quotes vary so much. Coolant leaks mostly come from a hose, the cap, the tank, the water pump or the thermostat housing, and you shouldn't drive if the temperature gauge climbs.

Other parts near the end of their life

Many of these cars are still on their first alternator, so test the battery before you blame it, as our page on how long an alternator lasts explains. A tired catalytic converter lights the check engine light, and a worn wheel bearing starts as a hum from one corner.

Should you buy a car with over 100k miles?

Yes, if the model's known fault has been dealt with and an independent inspection says the car is sound. The odometer alone tells you little, while what was done to the car tells you a lot.

These steps come from the FTC's used car guidance, plus the one this ranking adds, booking the inspection for the named fault:

  • Read the Buyers Guide. A dealer must show one on every used car it sells, but a private seller doesn't have to. It says whether the car is sold as is or with a warranty, and any spoken promise belongs written on it.
  • Run the VIN for open recalls. NHTSA's recall lookup and our free VIN decoder both list them. Our page on where to find the VIN shows the two places it always is.
  • Get a history report, then keep going. In the FTC's words, it "is not a substitute for an independent vehicle inspection."
  • Ask for the receipt for the named fault. A documented CVT, engine or clutch repair makes that fault less of an unknown.
  • Book an independent inspection for that fault. Ask for a written report with repair estimates. A seller who refuses the inspection is a reason to walk.
  • Take the overdue work off your offer. A belt that's due, worn tires or brakes all come off the price (our guide to reading the estimate shows how).

For what usually falls due at this mileage, see what to do at 100,000 miles. A car with a wet belt engine needs three extra checks, because its timing belt runs in the oil.

A car instrument cluster with the odometer reading 187,450 miles

What high mileage actually looks like

AI illustration by Oil & Miles

How do you check a high-mileage car in front of you?

Ask for the car to be cold when you arrive, because several faults show only in the first minutes. Then work down this list in order:

  1. Before it starts: the dipstick. On level ground, wipe it, push it back in and pull it again, and the oil should sit between the marks. Low or milky oil is a reason to walk away.
  2. Before it starts: the coolant tank. With the engine cold, read the level against the tank's marks, and never open the cap warm. An oily film or bubbles point to a head gasket.
  3. Before it starts: a code scanner. Plug a code reader into the port under the dash and turn the ignition on. Ask about any stored code and any self-test that reads not ready, meaning the car hasn't finished checking itself, which can be a sign the codes were cleared just before the sale.
  4. Cold start: the first seconds. Stand by the open hood while it starts. A light tick can be normal, but a deep knock that speeds up with the revs is a reason to walk away. Our engine knock guide says what the noise points to.
  5. Pulling away: drive, reverse, then move off gently. With your foot on the brake, drive and reverse should each take up promptly. Revs rising without speed mean slipping, and a judder on a Focus is its known clutch fault.
  6. Fully warm: the same drive again. Repeat the gentle pull-aways at the end of a proper drive, when everything is hot. On a CVT, noise, shudder or rising revs with no gain in speed mean a shop check first.
  7. Before you pay: the receipts. Ask for the service records and the paperwork on the model's known fault, with its date and mileage. No receipt means that repair may still be ahead.

If you can't run these yourself, a pre-purchase inspection at an independent shop does the same checks. It's worth more on these models than on most, because you can name the fault when you book it.

How was this ranked and where does it mislead?

We compare each model with itself, using the share of its own complaints that describe a repair of $1,000 or more. That share shows what owners write in about, not how often a car breaks.

A list that simply counts complaints mostly counts sales, since the Ford Focus has 7,537 complaints across these three model years and the Toyota RAV4 has 694. A raw count can't say how much of that gap is popularity, so the share sets the order instead.

Only models with 300 complaints or more are in, because fewer than that are too few to compare fairly. The spread runs from 2.1% to 25.8%, one complaint in fifty against one in four.

The three model years are the high-mileage market itself. At the federal average of 10,812 miles a year, a 2016 is near 110,000 miles now and a 2012 near 150,000.

What the share doesn't say

It isn't a probability: it doesn't say an Equinox is twelve times likelier to break than a Corolla. It says that when an Equinox owner does complain, about one in four describes a repair of $1,000 or more.

So read a high share as a pointer to the fault to inspect hardest. A low share means the complaints run to cheaper faults, not that the car never breaks.

Limits on this data

A complaint count reflects owners as much as cars, and it misses some faults. Three limits matter most when you read the list:

  • Complaints follow anger as well as metal. Whether an owner files tracks anger, warranty status and press coverage as much as the car. A class action or a recall drives filings on its own.
  • It's a safety file. The database exists for safety defects, so an expensive fault that never made a car unsafe is under-reported.
  • Owners write in their own words. A complaint that describes a fault without naming it can be missed, so every count here is a minimum.

The year columns move too: 11 of the 22 shifted six points or more from 2012 to 2016, six worse and five better. A newer year isn't automatically the safer buy.

Faults that arrived after 2016 can't appear here. The CR-V oil dilution complaints, fuel getting into the engine oil, concern the 2017–2022 models, all outside these three years.

A yellow mileage sticker reading 148,000 mi on a used car’s windshield

Before you buy a high mileage car

This page ranks each car by the share of its owners’ complaints that describe a repair of $1,000 or more, and names the fault they mention most. Other parts can still break. AI illustration by Oil & Miles

From the carmakers

Which of these faults did carmakers cover?

Kia and Hyundai recalled engines for bearing wear, while Nissan, GM and Ford gave longer warranties on the Rogue's CVT, the 2012 Equinox's oil use and the Focus dual-clutch. Nissan extended the CVT to 84 months or 84,000 miles on 2013–2017 Sentras and 2013–2016 Altimas, as it did on the Rogue, and the 2012 cars had no extension. Those extensions have run out on most cars, so ask a dealer to check the VIN.

Kia's settlement also covers 2011–2018 and some 2019 Optima, Sorento and Sportage GDI engines for life after the Knock Sensor Detection System update. Hyundai gives the Theta II on the 2011–2019 Sonata, 2013–2018 Santa Fe Sport and 2019 Santa Fe a Limited Lifetime Warranty.

Ask the seller for the receipts for that work. A dealer can also run the VIN to see whether a recall or program was done on the car.

Kia

Safety recall 17V-224

Machining errors during the engine manufacturing process may cause premature bearing wear within the engine.

Covers
Certain 2011–14 Optima, 2012–14 Sorento and 2011–13 Sportage.
Fix
The dealer inspects the engine and replaces it where needed.
Who pays
Recall
Hyundai

Safety recall 17V-226

Machining errors during the engine manufacturing process may cause premature bearing wear within the engine.

Covers
Certain 2013–14 Sonata and Santa Fe Sport. The 2011–12 Sonata was recalled earlier, under 15V-568, for metal debris in the engine.
Fix
The dealer inspects the engine and replaces it where needed.
Who pays
Recall
Ford

Customer satisfaction program 14M02 Supplement #7

Ford is extending the warranty coverage on the DPS6 automatic transmission TCM to 10 years of service or 150,000 miles

Covers
2012–16 Focus and 2011–15 Fiesta with the DPS6 dual-clutch: loss of drive, no-start or lack of power.
Fix
A new transmission control module, covered 10 years or 150,000 miles from the warranty start.
Who pays
May be under warranty
Nissan

Warranty extension CVT, Revision 2

The warranty is being extended from its original duration of 60 months/60,000 miles to 84 months/84,000 miles (whichever occurs first).

Covers
The CVT on the 2014–18 Rogue, 2015 Rogue Select and 2015–18 Pathfinder.
Fix
CVT repair or replacement, including the valve body and torque converter, covered 84 months or 84,000 miles, so these cars are now past it.
Who pays
Coverage ended
GM

Special coverage 16118-01, first issued April 2017

Some 2012 model year Chevrolet Equinox and GMC Terrain vehicles, equipped with a 2.4L engine, may exhibit excessive engine oil consumption

Covers
2012 Equinox and Terrain with the 2.4 four-cylinder, using more than a quart in under 2,000 miles from piston ring wear.
Fix
New pistons and rings, covered 7 years and 6 months or 120,000 miles, so these SUVs are now past it.
Who pays
Coverage ended
Ford

Customer satisfaction program 14M01 Supplement #7

Some of the affected vehicles may exhibit excessive transmission clutch shudder during light acceleration.

Covers
2012–14 Focus and 2011–14 Fiesta built to July 8, 2013, with the DPS6 dual-clutch.
Fix
Clutch, input shaft seals and software, covered 7 years or 100,000 miles, so these cars are now past it.
Who pays
Coverage ended

Conclusion

What to do next about a high-mileage car

Find the model's one known fault in the list, ask to see the car cold and then drive it warm, and book an independent inspection aimed at that fault with a written report. Walk away from a seller who won't allow one, and get the receipt for the known repair and a free recall lookup on the VIN before you pay.

Oil & Miles checks each step here against the federal complaint file and the carmakers' own documents.

High-mileage cars · before you buy

What to check on a high-mileage car, fault by fault

Common questions

Asked most often

Does a high complaint share mean the car will break?

No, it measures how many of the owners who complained described an expensive fault. It tells you what to inspect hardest on the car in front of you.

Why only 2012, 2014 and 2016?

They're old enough to be high-mileage purchases now and recent enough that the complaint file is full. Between them they cover the 110,000–150,000 miles most of these cars now show.

Should I avoid every car on the list?

No, because a Nissan with a documented CVT replacement beats an untouched one, and so does a Focus with the clutch pack done. The list tells you which question to ask the seller, and the answer can be reassuring.

Where do used cars with engine problems show up here?

Mostly in the engine-failure rows (Kia Optima, Hyundai Sonata). Some of those engines still have free coverage, set out in the carmakers' section, so ask a dealer to check the VIN.

What about brands not on the list?

They weren't part of this ranking, so the list says nothing about them either way. The 22 are mainstream models with enough complaints to be meaningful, and a model missing here simply wasn't measured.

Sources

  1. Kia engine settlement site, for the 2011–2018 and certain 2019 Optima, Sorento and Sportage with a 2.0L or 2.4L GDI engine, and lifetime coverage with the Knock Sensor Detection System update. Kia settlement administrator, read November 2, 2026
  2. NHTSA consumer complaints, for the 48,481 complaints on 22 models at the 2012, 2014 and 2016 model years, the named faults and the component shares. NHTSA, complaint file dated August 25, 2026, read September 1 and October 10, 2026
  3. Federal Highway Administration, Highway Statistics 2024, Table VM-1, for the 10,812 miles a year of a short-wheelbase light vehicle. FHWA, table updated February 2026, read November 5, 2026
  4. FTC, Buying a Used Car From a Dealer, for the Buyers Guide, independent inspections and history reports. Federal Trade Commission, April 2024, read October 10, 2026
  5. Hyundai Dealer Best Practice TXXI, July 13, 2020, for the class action settlement on connecting rod bearing coverage. Hyundai, read November 1, 2026
  6. NHTSA recall lookup, with recalls 17V-224 (Kia), 17V-226 and 15V-568 (Hyundai) and 17V-006 (Toyota). NHTSA, read October 10, 2026
  7. Ford program 14M02 Supplement #7, DPS6 transmission control module coverage, and Ford program 14M01 Supplement #7, DPS6 clutch shudder coverage. Ford via NHTSA, read October 10, 2026
  8. Nissan CVT warranty extension, Revision 2, Rogue and Pathfinder. Nissan via NHTSA, read October 10, 2026
  9. Nissan CVT warranty extensions of May 11, 2020 and May 23, 2023, for the 2013–2017 Sentra and 2013–2016 Altima (2020) and the 2018–2019 Sentra and 2017–2018 Altima (2023), at 84 months or 84,000 miles, and none for the 2012 cars. Nissan via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  10. Toyota Warranty Enhancement Program ZE5 dealer letter, updated February 15, 2018, for U760E torque converter shudder on certain 2012–2014 Camrys, 8 years or 150,000 miles. Toyota via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  11. Subaru bulletin 16-107-17R, revised March 13, 2018, for the 2010–2015 Outback CVT at 10 years or 100,000 miles. Subaru via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  12. Hyundai bulletin 22-EM-006H-2, November 2022, warranty extension TXXM, for engine damage from rod bearing wear on certain 2014–2016 Elantras with the 2.0L, 15 years or 150,000 miles. Hyundai via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  13. Ford program 19N08, August 14, 2019, for the DPS6 clutch on 2014–2016 Focus cars built July 9, 2013 to November 5, 2015, 7 years or 100,000 miles. Ford via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  14. Honda recall 15V-574, September 15, 2015, CVT software update on certain 2014–2015 Civics. NHTSA recall file, read November 5, 2026
  15. Subaru bulletin 02-157-14R, revised April 13, 2021, for oil consumption on 2011–2014 Foresters with the 2.5L FB, 8 years or 100,000 miles. Subaru via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  16. Volkswagen bulletin VWP-18-07, revised January 30, 2019, settlement coverage of the timing chain and tensioner on certain 2012–2014 Jettas, 10 years or 100,000 miles. Volkswagen via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  17. Honda Service Bulletin 16-012, Version 2, February 23, 2017, for a cold-start rattle from the VTC actuator on the 2014 CR-V. Honda via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  18. Toyota Warranty Enhancement Program ZH1 dealer letter, September 14, 2017, updated March 15, 2021, for U760E and U760F torque converter shudder on certain 2013–2015 RAV4s, 8 years or 150,000 miles. Toyota via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  19. Subaru bulletin 16-115-18, September 6, 2018, for the 2016–2017 Outback CVT at 10 years or 100,000 miles. Subaru via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  20. GM program N182195660, Revision 01, June 16, 2020, for piston replacement on certain 2016–2017 Malibus with the 1.5L turbo, in effect until June 30, 2022. GM via NHTSA, read November 5, 2026
  21. GM special coverage 16118-01, January 2020, first issued April 2017, 2012 Equinox and Terrain 2.4L oil consumption. GM via NHTSA, read October 10, 2026
  22. Hyundai Dealer Best Practice TXXI, January 19, 2022, for the Theta II Limited Lifetime Warranty on connecting rod bearing wear, for original and later owners, on the 2011–2019 Sonata, 2013–2018 Santa Fe Sport and 2019 Santa Fe. Hyundai via NHTSA, read November 4, 2026
  23. Photos from Wikimedia Commons: Chevrolet Equinox by IFCAR, public domain. Nissan Sentra by Mr.choppers, CC BY-SA 3.0, modified. Kia Optima by LuvsMG481, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Nissan Rogue by Elise240SX, CC BY-SA 4.0. Ford Focus by HJUdall, CC0. Toyota Camry by SsmIntrigue, CC BY-SA 4.0. Hyundai Sonata by EurovisionNim, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Nissan Altima by IFCAR, public domain. Subaru Outback by U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, public domain. Ford Escape by 2001FordRangerXLT, public domain, modified. Subaru Forester by Vauxford, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Hyundai Elantra by Elise240SX, CC BY-SA 4.0. Chevrolet Cruze by Cutlass, CC0, modified. Honda CR-V by Elise240SX, CC BY-SA 4.0. Volkswagen Jetta by MercurySable99, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Ford Fusion by SsmIntrigue, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Honda Accord by SsmIntrigue, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Toyota RAV4 by OSX, public domain. Honda Civic by Elise240SX, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Chevrolet Malibu by Kevauto, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Jeep Grand Cherokee by SsmIntrigue, CC BY-SA 4.0, modified. Toyota Corolla by Mr.choppers, CC BY-SA 3.0, modified.

AI illustration by Oil & Miles

How this was compiled

From NHTSA's consumer complaint file dated August 25, 2026, for 22 mainstream models at the 2012, 2014 and 2016 model years with 300 complaints or more. Component shares use NHTSA's own component classification on the same records.

The mileage band for each model year is our own arithmetic from the federal miles-a-year figure, not a published figure.

What we didn't do

We didn't obtain sales figures, so we didn't calculate complaints per vehicle sold. We didn't weight by severity, cost or mileage either: a failed engine and a shuddering clutch count the same here.

We didn't cover every model year, trim or engine, so a fault confined to one engine option is diluted across the model. We didn't verify individual complaints.

Written for the US market, compiled in September–November 2026. Worst means the highest share of a model's own owner complaints that describe a repair of $1,000 or more, and best the lowest. A low share isn't a car that never breaks. Near the bottom the counts are small (24 of 694 for the RAV4), so a few places mean little. This article is general information, not advice about your specific vehicle. See the disclaimer.